• Custom Cake Ordering Guide

    If you've landed on this page, here is the new link:


  • Custom Cake Ordering Guide

    *we have pre-made cookies & cream and strawberry vegan & dairy ice cream cakes available at our Downtown Orlando location, available first come first serve. You do not need to place an order for our pre-made cakes.*


    This guide below is for custom cakes.

    Shapes, sizes, and prices vary ranging from $37 - $55. The ordering guide below is for custom ice cream cakes.


    Celebrate the victories in life with a handmade custom ice cream cake!

    • Pick-up required. Unless otherwise noted for Sanford pick up, the pick-ups are at our Downtown Orlando location at 420 E Church Street. Sanford pick-ups must give 1 week notice. 
    • 7 days are needed to place an order. If there is a rush order, please email us first at production@thegreenerycreamery.com and we will do our best to accommodate. A rush order of $5 will be added. We have a selection of pre-made vegan and dairy cakes at the store that you can purchase if less than 7 full days are given. 
    • Regrettably, we cannot complete writing on any cakes at this time.  
    • Once this form is filled out, we will email confirmation along with the appropriate invoice. The invoice needs to be paid in full prior to pick-up.

    SIZE ONE Heart-shaped cakes are approximately 5.75" across and 3" tall. Feeds 4-6 people. $37
    SIZE TWO Ice cream cakes are 6" inches across by 3" tall. Feeds 6-8 people. $50
    SIZE THREE Sponge cake and ice cream cakes are 6" across by 5" to 6" tall. Feeds 10-15 people. $70

    SIZE FOUR cookie cake (no ice cream). Feeds 2 -4 people. $24

    SIZE FIVE brownie cake (no ice cream). Feeds 2 -4 people. $24